After Diane Hathaway resigned from the Michigan Supreme Court amid fraud charges O'Brien was seen as a strong candidate to replace her. Judge OBrien says thats not what he meant and says he would tell family members to file a petition for instruction as well. Courts say that they are protecting a ward and acting in a wards best interests, but who is to define what the best interests of any individual person are? Two heavyweight attorneys from Chalgian & Tripp and Kemp KleinPhilip E. Harter and Thomas V. Trainer, respectivelyserved as co-editors for the revised edition of. Informal and Unsupervised Estate Proceeding, niversity of Detroit School of Law, Juris Doctor 1988, Oakland County District Court Magistrate (52-2 Clarkston) 2001 -2008, Assistant Oakland County Prosecutor 1991-1995, Michigan Court of Appeals Research Attorney 1988 1990 Served as research attorney for Hon. He will continue to be pro-guardianship. width: 57%; She served as a member of the Mediator Standards of Conduct Committee, and as Team Leader for Washtenaw County American Inn of Court, 2011-2013. An order recently, issued from Washtenaw County Judge. If you've got family members giving you a hard time, if you're concerned about how it might look. Like Geller and Paul, in a statement to this investigation, Michigan Elder Justice Initiative Managing Attorney Alison Hirschel was optimistic. Oakland County Judge John N. O'Brien who combined eloquence of personality with his knowledge of law died Tuesday in Beaumont Hospital, Royal Oak.A graduate of the University of Detroit, Judge O'Brien was first elected to the bench 1n 1972. Falk remainsdetermined to get federal legislators to listen, despite push-back from pro-guardian advocacy groups who insist that guardianship abuse is rare and those journalists whoinvestigateit exaggeratethe problem. It's so incredibly demeaning, said Nessel. Prior to his election, he handled general civil, criminal, and probate matters in private practice for thirteen years (1995 to 2008). Try again later. width: 150px; (c)2023 Daily Tribune, Royal Oak, Mich. The fiduciary taskforce assigned to handle former ADDMS cases, was led by John Chase, Jr., the Wayne County Probate lawyer who, in 1995, investigated the activities of Guardian Inc. and was accused in a 2011 lawsuit of conspiring to drain the Rosa Parks estate. On March 27, 2019, Haddock filed a petition to remove Yun as guardian and conservator. Please reset your password. We are taking into account everything youre saying. Sorry! The people of my county are wonderful people, said OBrien in the video. font-size: .9em; However, Michigan Supreme Court Justices Bernstein and [Megan] Cavanagh seem very determined and committed to this new effort. Theyve been breaking the rules with impunity for so long that they dont see a problem with it. Feeling as if it was getting out of hand, Catherine offered help. Meanwhile, Yun had started work on the sale of Haddocks home. It wasappalling. In November 2002, Sterling Heights Councilwoman Kathryn George was elected to the Macomb County Probate Court bench. . Offender: Judge Daniel A. O'Brien Country: USA State: Michigan City: Pontiac Address: 1200 N. Telegraph Category: Miscellaneous Related Complaints Wayne county probate courtJudge Martin Mahar hot headed judge, hes the king of his courtroom. Before filing it with the court, she faxed the letter to Yuns office. He was immediately reminded that his three minutes were up and that the justices could not address specific cases. Verify and try again. He was elected to the bench in November 2008. Daniel A. O'Brien, Oakland County Probate Court - Administrative Orders and Policies, Oakland County Probate Court - Hon. (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.). Web Extra | Judge O'Brien at Michigan Guardianship Association conference. I thought that they were doing their jobs. Daniel A. O'Brien Presiding Judge of Estates and Trusts About Daniel A. O'Brien Elected to Oakland County Probate Court November 2008 Probate Judge 2009 - present U niversity of Detroit School of Law, Juris Doctor 1988 Oakland County District Court Magistrate (52-2 Clarkston) 2001 -2008 Assistant Oakland County Prosecutor 1991-1995 font-weight: bold; In Michigan, nearly a quarter-centurys worth ofguardianship scandals and Task Forceswhich have resulted in little or no change or punitive measures, appear to echo the concept as defined by 18th-century British Judge Sir William Blackstone. In 1996, following a scandal involving private guardianshipcompanyGuardian Inc. of WayneCounty,which was found to have committed acts of malfeasancein cases involving hundreds of wards at the Wayne CountyProbateCourt, Mack was asked to join the panel of the Michigan Supreme Courts Guardianship Task Forceas a representative of the Michigan Probate Judges Association. Judge DANIEL P. O'BRIEN presiding. Mack stated that many of the issues raised in the Auditor Generals report were matters of judicial discretion and decisions were made at duly noted hearings with everyone having the opportunity to testify in open court.. Please enable scripts and reload this page. I can appoint a guardian for someone who has an illness because theyre incapacitated, he, At an April 14, 2010, joint session of Michigans House of Representatives and Senate, thenMichigan Supreme Court Chief Justice Marilyn Kelly. However, after Catallo aired a second report involving Caring Hearts, Nessels office refused to confirm or deny an investigation into the company. United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. We try to maximize that safety by not honoring their independence.. Don't we owe that to seniors in our state, said Nessel. Attorney P# (12345) Select Date. There is 1 volunteer for this cemetery. 37 [email protected]; [email protected] download PDF bio Please Share Fee Schedule Articles / Publications Daily Journal Profile Profile Judge DANIEL P. O'BRIEN presiding. Once a probate judges term is up, they are rarely opposed for reelection. This time, the justices decided to take action. What we really need to look at is "Who are we giving badges and guns to". Are you sure that you want to delete this photo? Judge DANIEL P. O'BRIEN presiding. Hon. Even as Mack penned his 2003 memo assuring the State Court Administrator of working safeguards in probatecourtrooms, another probate scandal brewed, this time in Macomb County. Catherine and Podvin deny any meeting ever occurred before the July 10 conference in Yuns office. Once the Order has been signedby the Judge and take to the ProbateCounter for filing, there will beno needto go on the record and the parties will be released. State Bar of Michigan, Ancient Order of Hibernians, Former Hon. Although in its 1998 report, the Task Force made multiple recommendations, only one was enacted. National Association to Stop Guardian Abuse(NASGA) Director Marcia Southwick believes such preferential treatment of the young in comparison to seniors is ingrained in American culture. font-size: .9em; Eventually, you begin to wonder, whats the point? Not only my mom and I, but thousands of people are being ripped off and abused. Investor Mikhail Haikin (listed on the petition as Mike) bought the home for $137,505. The reason as to why Hallmark approved a petition lacking any corroborating information for the sale price is unknown. Which memorial do you think is a duplicate of John O'Brien (208457091)? Thomas M. Cooley Law Schools Professionalism Advisory Committee; South Haddock added that she was not told when her home was sold by the former public administrator. She served as the Court's Administrative Judge in 2014 and 2015. When she was in the emergency room, I could hear the nurses and paramedics talking about the state of her home, Catherine remembers. Parties should check in 15 minutes prior to their Zoom hearing. Judge O'Brien's ruling appears to contradict an Isabella County judge's ruling in a case involving another dispensary known as Compassionate Apothecary, according to Rockind. And I do that by focusing on the person whose name is on the case. This can lead to guardianship petitions being filed when it is not appropriate and to guardianship being imposed when it is not warranted by the facts and circumstances., Prisoners have more rights than people under guardianship, Hoyle says. They can appeal me to the Court of Appeals. (RCOC) has named two new managers: Jeff O'Brien has been named manager of the Subdivisio. Are you sure that you want to remove this flower? John Yun wont get into trouble for neglect or for not taking care of the patient.. Find contact's direct phone number, email address, work history, and more. From his earliest days as a Wayne County Probate Court Judge, Mack remained both a pervasive and highly influential presence in the anatomy of Michigan probate law. $47.43 - $74.63; Full-time; San jose, CA 95103; Easy Apply . Two heavyweight attorneys from Chalgian & Tripp and Kemp KleinPhilip E. Harter and Thomas V. Trainer, respectivelyserved as co-editors for the revised edition of The Michigan Guardianship and Conservatorship Handbook. I told him that wed been calling all the time and he just said, We have no record of that., Yet, Yuns own accountsbill Haddock for at least a dozen occasions during which members of her family had contacted his office. In June 2014, Voice of Detroit reported that George issued an order authorizing the Grosse Pointe Farms, Michigan police to forcibly remove Mauliani from Lenettes home; one which they allegedly executed at gun-point. We have set your language to font-size: 1.2em; I believe that public confidence in probate courts is at stake, Corriganconcluded. George was removed as Chief Judge and assigned to Macomb County ProbateCourts mental health division. in the jurisdiction of Oakland County. I tell everyone, not just guardians, not just professional guardians, but any family member you have a problem, you try to work it out with your brother, your sister, your parent, whatever it is. (Ret.) Families attending Elder Abuse Task Force Listening Sessions to air their complaints were told to leave materials with the Attorney Generals staff or call her office directly. This content was created by a Daily Kos Community member. An email has been sent to the person who requested the photo informing them that you have fulfilled their request, There is an open photo request for this memorial. He has called Hays County home, along with his wife and daughter, for a decade. It was like they completely dismissed the idea, and they werent going to consider anything else.. Hon. O'Brien, Gregory | ADR Services, Inc. Hon. Katherine says no one from Yuns office called her to let her know. Hoyle asserts that 73 percent of Michigans developmentally disabled population are under some form of guardianship. I think the Michigan Supreme Court has had enough and there will be consequences for judges who do not follow the law.. Try again. were not accurate or valid. To use this feature, use a newer browser. Engels hurriedly summed up his argument. Andruccioli from her role as public administrator. }, Daniel Patrick O'Brien is a judge for the 6th Circuit Court in Oakland County, Michigan. Because of the close associations and business ties of court officers and the law firms involved, a fullindependent audit is recommended.. I saw a question at one of the earlier sessions about selling a house. Guardianship reform, disability and senior advocacy groupsbelieve the reasonso many Americans, media outlets and major civil rights organizations ignore guardianships monumental flaws and catalytic, paralleled atrocities is rooted in UnitedStatesculture. Twelve years earlier, he was embroiled in the Wayne County Probate Court when his mother Gertrude was declared legally incapacitated. Send Flowers Oakland County Judge John N. O'Brien who combined eloquence of personality with his knowledge of law died Tuesday in Beaumont Hospital, Royal Oak. I thought you might like to see a memorial for Judge John Newell O'Brien I found on Findagrave.com. Advertisers want to sell to the young, so they are a part of pushing the narrative that the elderly dont count., The problem is Michigans judges have stereotypical notions that older adults are running inexorably downhill with respect to their mental and physical capacities, Geller asserts. In a report issued January 2005, the office concluded that Michigan statute presumes that a court ward has interested persons who are both willing to serve and have the wards best interests at heart, but this is not the case for many court wards. His memberships have included the Oakland County Bar Association, the Michigan Probate Judges Association, and the Southeast Michigan Probate Judges Association. Daniel P. O'Brien is a judge for the Sixth Circuit Courtof Michigan in Oakland County. Justice of the Peace 2-1. background-color: grey; In case, therefore, any guardian abuses his trust, the court will check and punish him.. Therefore, you will want to look for an experienced Michigan Criminal Defense Attorney who has appeared several times before Judge O'brien and schedule a consultation. display: inline-block; color: white; Im headed in that direction. Kevins Law expanded the definitions of persons requiring treatment and allowed for family members and guardians to be able to file a probate court petition ordering outpatient mental care. Her Judicial Staff Attorney Christine A. Waid used to work for former Oakland County Public Administrator Jon Munger. This relationship is not possible based on lifespan dates. The reason for the ex-parte petition is unknown. The Whall Groups reports were never made public. Following a half . Non-Domestic Sexual Assault Against a Minor, In order to better serve the attorneys and litigants appearing in Judge O'Brien's courtroom, we have adopted the following guidelines. The SCAO engaged in a two-year review of the Auditor Generals findings. This isnt a joke. The families, advocates and few attorneys who fight back against what they allege is massive corruption at the Detroit-area Oakland County Probate Court face an invulnerable fortress, a description once conferred upon the court itself. However, it did not apply to individuals with drug or alcohol issues, those with Alzheimers or other disorders affecting the brain. Learn more. Macks 1998 campaign to retain his position as probate court judge was overwhelmingly supported by attorneys. University of Detroit, Mercy School of Law, .infobox { State Bar of Michigan ID Number: P39912 Since 1987 Professional Associations State Bar of Michigan # P39912 Member 1987 - Current Contact & Map US Attorney's Office Eastern District of Michigan 211 W Fort St Ste 2001 Detroit, MI 48226 Telephone: (313) 226-9715 Fax: (313) 226-5464 Email John N. O'Brien II Download vCard In November, 2014 mother and daughter were. August 12 in Marquette, Michiganwas the final stop of her Listening Tour. Year:1990, University of Detroit, Mercy School of Law } After graduating from law school, he began his legal career as an assistant prosecuting attorney with the Office of the Prosecuting Attorney in Oakland County (1994 to 1995). There's all sorts of options. Fraser, Munger and Mays former Kemp Klein colleague Andruccioli was one of the subjects of a 2017 media investigation alleging she was one of a group of public administrators who had worked alongside a Michigan realtor to open probate cases on deceased estates without notifying next-of-kin. courtroom,any petitionsthat included a recommendation of ADDMS as a guardian and conservator. Even if they were, one case is one case too many. at the University of Detroit, Mercy School of Law in 1994. There was time to prepare to deflect criticism and to spin the story, she writes. 1933 - 2011. When you are having problems with your case, file a petition for instruction, ok for me to make the decision. Judge DANIEL P. O'BRIEN presiding. Her husband was an electrician before he passed away, leaving Haddock to raise her two children alone. '. The states Judicial Tenure Commission (JTC) conducts investigations in secrecy. She has $6,000 left, Catherine says. The 7 Investigators have been documenting examples of guardianships gone wrong across Southeast Michigan since 2017. Despite her allegedly-problematic tenure in Macomb County, in 2014 George was assigned as a visitingjudgeto the Wayne County ProbateCourt where she oversaw the case of Mailauni Williams and her mother Lennette. In October of 1967 there were organized draft-card "turn-ins" all over the country; in San Francisco alone, three hundred draft cards were returned to the government. Do I fail? I'm saying that's the perception that people have in the Oakland County Probate Court, is that there is this very cozy relationship between the professional guardians and between the judges, and that regular people are not going to get a fair shake.. Both Catherine and Podvin say they were shocked when Hallmark granted the public administrators request for 45 days to come up with receipts for each of his charges. Weve updated the security on the site. granted the under-sale of her home by her conservator. An adjournment Order shall be filed withthe clerk. Judge Jennifer Callaghan began her career as an Assistant Attorney General, In 2010 was hired by now-former Oakland County Public Administrator John Yunas an associate attorney and regularly took guardianship and conservatorship cases at the Oakland County Probate Court. Under Judge Macks plan, courts would consider a persons condition and also have the authority to appoint a guardian who can consent to involuntary mental health treatment on the persons behalf, she said. During his judicial tenure, OBrien has served as presiding judge of estates and trusts. Attorneys and GALs should contact the Judges Clerk on any case they know to be contested and will require testimony. On August 29, 2022 a case was filed .infobox p { According to the Commission's2018 annual report, it received complaints against 475 judges. } Previously sponsored memorials or famous memorials will not have this option. If you have a story for Heather, please email her [email protected] or call 248-827-4473. I was told that the judge would never allow me to be guardian because my mother had objected and because I had a bankruptcy, she says. border:1px solid #FFB81F; At a hearing the following June, Yun resigned. Minutes from a September 8, 2018annual meeting of the Probate and Estate Planning Section noted that its members would oppose the bill and that the Section had provided alternate language to the sponsor.. Office E-mail: [email protected]. vertical-align: top; He simply attached a July 2017 receipt showing that the taxes had been paid. allegedly imprisoned in their own home by a Sterling Heights, Michigan guardianship company Caring Hearts of Michigan, Inc.. ce again, it was discovered that George regularly assignedCaring Hearts to guardianship and conservatorship cases. .courts-header { font-size:150%;background-color:#334aab;color:white;} margin-bottom: 0; Top donors included May and Chase. Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Daniel O'Brien's order denying the city's request appears to put up a major hurdle in the city's attempt to remove itself from the Oakland County Public . Judge Tammy O'Brien was appointed to the Summit County Court of Common Pleas in 2011, elected in 2012 and re-elected in 2014 and 2020. in the jurisdiction of Oakland County. Laws are no good if no one is prepared to enforce them., You have to return to a system of law, she says. The idea won Mack universal acclaim from the media, peers and the Michigan Supreme Court as an advocate for the mentally ill. By 2015, the Michigan Supreme Court appointed Mack to the position of State Court Administrator, one that he told Stateside allowed him the ability to work more closely with the Michigan legislature in order to ensure support for his initiatives. } O'Brien Barton Wieck & Joe PLLC . After problems with Lennettes pregnancy and delivery at a Detroit hospital left Mailauni developmentally disabled, Lennette sued the hospital and won a multi-million-dollar settlement for herself and her daughter, the disposition of which,ultimately, led mother and daughter to Georges courtroom. Five years after theTask Force had made its recommendations, the Michigan Supreme Court justices received an October 23, 2003, report from the Office of the Auditor General that reviewed conservatorship cases filed in Wayne, Washtenaw, Calhoun, Jackson and Huron Counties. No comment was received. Hoyle asserts that 73 percent of Michigans developmentally disabled population are under some form of guardianship. Please enable scripts and reload this page. I hear about Oakland County more than any of the 82 other counties, said Nessel. DANIEL P. O'BRIEN Degree: B.S. Help expand Ballotpedia's elections coverage - volunteer with us. Michigan Circuit Court The Clerk will then arrange for the case to be heard on a non-motion call docket. Looking back, Catherine feels she was duped from the start. He hasnt done a thing for me, she says. As Americans, we have to work on the idea that our future is going to entail us being not as strong, clear or as healthy as we are now. In addition to her judicial experience, OBrien has been active in a number of community groups serving families and children, including serving as an adviser to Crossroads for Youth, a nonprofit treatment agency that serves at-risk children facing a variety of challenges. Select from premium Susan Tripp of the highest quality. The report does not match Yuns account line itemsthat only show the August 25 and December 27 visits, the formerof which Yun billed her for twice on the same day. Resend Activation Email, Please check the I'm not a robot checkbox, If you want to be a Photo Volunteer you must enter a ZIP Code or select your location on the map. Judge Linda S. Hallmark was appointed as Oakland County Probate Court Judge in 1997 by thenGovernor John Engler (R) after spending three years in private practice at Mays thenlaw firm May & May, PC. Some examples suggest that protected individuals estates may have lost money either through negligence or wrong-doing., , former Macomb County Probate Court Chief Judge Pamela Gilbert OSullivan recalled numerous occasions [that] I had conversations with the State Court Administrators Office in an effort to seek its assistance regarding Judge Georges failure or refusal to comply with the Courts practices, policies, and procedures., lawsuit filed by Houseys attorney along with a. authored by thenState Court Administrator Carl Gromek offer some details of the Whall Groups findings. With the aid of a walker, she was able to move around her small bedroom and adjoining bathroom. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/208457091/john-newell-o'brien. or don't show this againI am good at figuring things out. He also served as an assistant prosecuting attorney for Oakland County in 1995 and 1996. Director of Public Policy at The ARC Michigan, Dohn Hoyle was a fellow panelist. Prosecuting Attorney for Oakland County, 1995-1996, Member: He can never mean to do an improper thing. Found more than one record for entered Email, You need to confirm this account before you can sign in. www.judgemo.org. Officer Brendan O'Brien was a 30 year old police officer with the Oakland Police Department. No formal criminal investigations have been announced by Nessel into the activities of public administrators in Michigans probate courts. We didnt want her to go there, Catherine says. How can you protect someone by taking away their rights? Meanwhile, the transfer ofHaddock to a home where she can stay with family as well as the restoration of hername onherbank accounts has been the least of their problems. America is driven by a consumer culture. background-color: grey; It never dawned on me that they would swoop in and take over because my mom had money and that they would keep her indefinitely. However, Nessel didnt mention the push-back that proposed reforms and changes to existing legislation has historically received from individuals such as Mack, the Probate Judge and Michigan Guardianship Associations and the Probate and Estate Planning Section of the State Bar of Michigan (SBM). Probate judges can appoint a guardian for anyone deemed legally incapacitated. We would go out every week to a restaurant or to church, but we just wouldnt talk about it.. O'Brien was an attorney in private practice at Cummings, McClorey, Davis & Acho PLC, with an emphasis in civil litigation, for 17 years before becoming a circuit court judge in late 1998. text-align: center; Watch on. Try again later. O'Brien has been on the 6 th Circuit Court in Oakland County since being elected in 1998 and is the presiding judge of the Oakland Civil-Criminal Division. Your new password must contain one or more uppercase and lowercase letters, and one or more numbers or special characters. Distributed by Tribune Content . Calls to Independence Village was not returned. According to a March 2018 report released by the National Council on Disabilities, an estimated 1.3 million Americans with disabilities have been directly impacted by guardianship. The combined length of any motion and brief, or of a response and brief, may not exceed 20 pages double spaced, exclusive of attachments and exhibits. For years, the 7 Investigators have been exposing problems in the guardianship system. We wanted this Taskforce to be action-oriented, she said. She told us Yuns office had called them and told them we were coming but the facility didnt have to talk to us. As she grew older, and after my brother and I moved out, she became very lonely. It was really far away from all of us. In my view, the Michigan Supreme Court has an exclusive duty and responsibility for what these judges are doing because the Judicial Tenure Commission wont do anything about them, he says. font-weight: bold; The office is open to customers in person 8:00 am to 4:00 pm. However, it did not apply to individuals with drug or alcohol issues, those with Alzheimers or other disorders affecting the brain. As manager of this memorial you can add or update the memorial using the Edit button below. Farmington Hills, Michigan attorney Steven G. Cohen, who was penalized by the Michigan Attorney Grievance Commission after he accused Wayne County Judge Freddie Burton, Jr. and attorneys John Chase, Jr. and Melvin Jefferson, Jr. of draining the Rosa Parks estate, found Macks appointment one of the oddest and scariest things Id ever seen., As Chief Judge of the Wayne County Probate Court, he presided over and protected a very abusive court, Cohen says. The purpose of the pilot project is to study the effectiveness of electronic filing of probate documents in relation to providing the public and legal community access to . Prior to his election, he handled general civil, criminal, and probate matters in private practice for thirteen years (1995 to 2008). Learn more about managing a memorial . Adjunct Professor Oakland Community College, Former James Ryan Jr.'s company Public Affairs Associates (PAA) has longstanding ties to Democrat Governor Gretchen Whitmer and was among the top donors for her inauguration committee. Honorable Francis X. O'Brien. To view a photo in more detail or edit captions for photos you added, click the photo to open the photo viewer. Prior to his election, he had worked as a private practice attorney since 1998. Case Evaluation It was a really quick hearing, Catherine says. Our reporting caught the attention of Attorney General Dana Nessel, who formed the Elder Abuse Task Force and introduced legislation in the hopes of improving the guardianship system. Oakland County Probate Chief Judge Kathleen Ryan, retiring probate judge Elizabeth Pezzetti, and Judges Linda S. Hallmark and Daniel A. O'Brien attended as "Honored Guests." Ultimately . A January 2000 hearing in Flint, Michigan, addressed the contributions of attorneys to judicial campaigns and the possible quid pro quos that could arise from them. Until we see prosecutions against these guardians and courts, this is going to go on. lthough Nesselhas repeatedly said that Public Administratorstake on guardianships and conservatorships as private attorneys,she did not clarify if or how thedecision would provide any tangible changes to their actions as guardians and conservators. Web Extra | AG Nessel on Judge O'Brien's comments. In January 2018, Oakland County Probate Court Register Jill Koney Daly, who had held the position for more than a decade, suddenly announced her retirement to take a part-time job as an attorney at the statewide estate probate and elder law firm Chalgian & Tripp. It allows the worst propensities in human nature, hatred, lust for power, revenge and deceit, to take root and grow.
La Voix 6 Duel, Articles J